I was very surprised to discover that makeup legend Dick Smith was attached to an attempt to bring "The Shadow Over Innsmouth" to the big screen back in the 90s. These are two of his test sculpts from the failed project, apparently taken from a writeup in an issue of "Fangoria". Later today I'll try and track down a copy of the article.
Update: A kind reader sent over a scan of the article in question. The "Fangoria" story seems to be the only notable press coverage the project received, other than some teaser posters and a color ad in "Variety". Instead of "The Shadow Over Innsmouth" Dick Smith ended up working on "The Godfather III". Now that's a horror story.
Just right click and open the image in another tab to see the full sized page.