Nazis! Aztecs! Cthulhu! It's not only unabashedly pulpy, but this Cthulhu mod for Crysis has some wonderful prop mockups.
I'm not sure if Christian Matzke is officially involved in this project, but I believe much of the prop material on display was originally of his creation. His Propping Up the Mythos website is a treasure trove of propmaking information as well as the direct inspiration for my own efforts.