If you have an ALDI market nearby you may want to pay them a visit. Their "Sparkling Spiced Pumpkin Cider" has a cool bottle that's easily re-purposed for fantasy and pirate LARPs. The cider inside gets generally favorable reviews online, but it's a bit too sweet for my tastes. At $2 a bottle it's a bargain, and I mean that literally. Just ordering this kind of bottle from a supplier would cost you far more. Remove the labeling and bale, add a cork, and you have a serviceable, food safe prop. If the bale indents are an issue cover the throat of the bottle with a leather wrap.